Press "Enter" to skip to content

One Of Us Is Lying Series Review: Another good young adult adaptation added to the stable

The cliché setting, notwithstanding, Erica Saleh’s adaptation of Karen M. McManus’ younger adult thriller/drama original is one participating shuffle. Whereas observing One Of Us Is Lying, it is doubtless you’ll perhaps perhaps’t support but remove titles akin to 13 Reasons Why and Terror. Yes, they might per chance well perhaps perhaps all belong to the younger adult model, but they additionally characteristic overlapping topics that are noteworthy to ignore. In its tone and barely realistic depiction of American teenage actuality, the conceal is more identical to Terror, setting itself other than 13 Reasons Why (whose final two seasons drew a blank with an overdose of melodrama). The sequence is enviornment in Bayview Excessive, where becoming in is the norm. Each person (successfully, nearly) places on a public face for their peers. Of us that are unafraid to be themselves are veritably relegated to ‘social outcast’ enviornment. The remarkably vivid Simon Kelleher (Designate McKenna) is one such student. His only buddy Janae (Jessica McLeod) and him sit collectively, passing sarcastic remarks about their classmates’ incapacity to be folk, to be legitimate. He takes this endeavour one step extra with his app, posting revelatory files bearing on his classmates. A day of detention for five college students ends in tragedy when Simon suffers an anaphylactic shock after ingesting from the water cooler. His sudden, surprising passing raises questions about the final four college students within the room, all of whom Simon threatened to pronounce. All five got detention for something abnormal. Why used to be the EpiPen missing from the nurse’s enviornment sooner or later of his assault? When the investigation guidelines out unintended dying, the police’s focal point falls on the totally different four: Bronwyn (Marianly Tejada), Bayview’s star student and future valedictorian, her sights enviornment on Yale; Addy (Annalisa Cochrane), a current cheerleader who hangs out with the frosty teens; Cooper (Chibuikem Uche), the college’s champion baseball pitcher eyeing the foremost league; and Nate (Cooper van Grootel), a drug vendor with a prison file and advanced home lifestyles.

Creator: Erica Saleh 


Solid: Marianly Tejada, Annalisa Cochrane, Designate McKenna, Chibuikem Uche


Streaming On: Netflix



For the outer world, these highschoolers might per chance perhaps appear to compare neatly into pre-assigned containers, but there’s lots more to the myth than meets the conception. Each of them has motive to wipe Simon out for the risk he posed, but so does the leisure of the college, for that matter. The genius child sick of pretence and hypocrisy it appears dug enough to amass filth on every person, including lecturers.


One Of Us Is Lying taps into the advanced and confounding world of teen lives. The overwhelming need to be seen in a particular gain others or upright be seen, is the underlying theme of the conceal. Each person has just a few secrets and methods rising up, and some might per chance perhaps now not even be that astronomical of a deal, as we’re to search out out. But the astronomical ones have a tendency to resurface if now not celebrated for too long. Your complete teens comprise something to lose, right here; Ivy league college potentialities, a reputedly favorable relationship, a promising athletic career, and freedom to upright leave.



It’s miles fine to explore nuance within the central characters’ personalities after they are forced to work collectively. At the beginning, they are highly suspicious of one one other, but as time passes, we learn an aspect (camaraderie, empathy, determining) they veritably veil from the leisure of the enviornment. With a conception to conceal their innocence, private secrets and methods reach to the fore. Even particular person family dynamics play a astronomical part within the youngsters’ existence. Bronwyn and Cooper comprise mighty riding on their younger shoulders, and their of us preserve reminding them of what’s at stake. Addy’s mom appears to be only fervent on her daughter’s appears to be like to be, now not taking a moment to empathise with her about the continued danger; with the social media buzz being generated, her mom ludicrously suggests that she need to exhaust this likelihood to turn out to be an influencer. Nate’s unstable childhood explains many of his past misdemeanours. And yet, their proper attainable comes out after they’re keep in eventualities beyond their consolation zone. This complexity of characterisation is captured within the writing.



The police investigation, nonetheless, is poorly presented. For the high college teens to outwit legislation enforcement so with out issues, and at nearly each given flip, is pretty implausible. The Extinguish Club (because the four suspects are christened) meets in secret to focus on strategy, being carefully watched by an unknown entity. The effect on earth are the investigators? If the youngsters are indeed suspects, how reach the police isn’t monitoring their telephones? Some bland questioning by the lead officer on the case (in a mock-threatening command, no less) is neither believable nor spectacular.


One Of Us Is Lying has been picked up for a second season. It’s miles bigger than seemingly the anecdote follows the events from Karen M. McManus’ follow-up, One Of Us Is Subsequent. Sterling performances, a favorable soundtrack, first fee pacing, and writing that doesn’t crawl into melodramatic cliches, build definite that Season 2 would per chance be awaited!

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *